TPO Ruling on Tenant Reference Charges

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • TPO Ruling on Tenant Reference Charges

    A recent ruling by TPO concered an applicant who had paid a deposit and reference charges to an
    agent, and who had also signed a tenancy agreement, but the landlord hadn't.

    The landlord decided that the references were not "good enough" so declined a tenancy and the agent refunded the deposit but not the reference costs. The applicant appealed to TPO and lost! An agent only has to refund reference charges if the landlord pulls out, if references were otherwise satisfactory. The only other situation where reference charges could be retained is the failure to disclose relevant information by the applicant.

    The OFT cites in its guidance that it would be 'unfair' not to refund charges otherwise.
    The advice I give should not be construed as a definitive answer, and is without prejudice or liability. You are advised to consult a specialist solicitor or other person of equal legal standing.

  • #2
    Thanks for the info, Paul.

    "Not good enough" and "otherwise satisfactory" seem rather subjective. So this begs the question of how to determine this.
    Were the references bad enough that no landlord would reasonably accept them?
    Should the landlord inform the prospective tenant of what he would consider satisfactory, or a deal breaker, in advance?

    Comment

    Latest Activity

    Collapse

    • Help with this agent
      robbie31
      My wife and I are expats who have been renting our property through an agent for 5 years. We currently own a four bedroom property (for bedrooms including a loft extensions) In October 2016, the previous tenants move out and the current occupants moved in. We were sent the documents with a recommendation...
      13-07-2017, 12:03 PM
    • Reply to Help with this agent
      tatemono
      You paid 10% of what on top of a management fee?

      What does your contract say about this? If the contract makes no mention of a "get out" fee then it will cost you nothing to dispense with their services.

      Is there a notice period for cancelling the contract with the...
      16-07-2017, 09:29 AM
    • Reply to Help with this agent
      MrShed
      That would depend wholly on the terms of your contract with the agent. There's no "standard" procedure I'm afraid....
      16-07-2017, 06:19 AM
    • Reply to Help with this agent
      robbie31
      Good afternoon

      Thank you for your excellent advice. I meant about compensating the agent. This is the question in a better way. At the beginning of the tenancy we paid 10% for a finders fee / advertising / searches etc as well as a management fee taken from the rent. If we decide to cancel...
      16-07-2017, 03:26 AM
    • Reply to Help with this agent
      MrShed
      Sorry not sure your question makes a lot of sense. Why would you have to compensate tenants for you changing agent? Apologies if I am misreading this?
      15-07-2017, 16:49 PM
    • Reply to Help with this agent
      robbie31
      If we were to change the agent (the contract end on the 28th August) would be be tied and have to compensate the tenants until that date?...
      15-07-2017, 07:30 AM
    • Reply to Help with this agent
      robbie31
      Point made Mr Shed. Thanks for the upfront advice....
      15-07-2017, 07:05 AM
    • Reply to Help with this agent
      MrShed
      A few things here:

      1) you explicitly said above the issue was distance. You can understand why I thought therefore the issue was distance.
      2) the average compensation of the ombudsman is completely irrelevant. What matters is your specific case which could be over or under the average....
      15-07-2017, 06:31 AM
    • Reply to Help with this agent
      robbie31
      The issue is not really about distance. We are in a dilemma. My wife seems to think that if we make a complaint the agent can cancel our contract. This would mean finding a new agent and paying fees etc. Monies we do not have. We have spoken to the Ombudsman who informed us that we should have been...
      14-07-2017, 23:58 PM
    • Reply to Help with this agent
      MrShed
      I dont understand why distance makes an issue with you raising the behaviour of the agent with their professional body?
      14-07-2017, 15:58 PM
    Working...
    X