Letting agent ‘decorated’ my flat without consulting me

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Letting agent ‘decorated’ my flat without consulting me

    Hello and Happy New Year. I recently had a new tenant move in to my London flat, and as part of the tenancy agreement I said I would redo the skirting boards and replace the curtain rail. I duly contacted both the tenant - whose details the agent supplied - and the contractor who takes care of all the work on my property, and the last I heard from him, he had spoken with the tenant and arranged a visit. I do not use the agents’ contractors at all. That was at the beginning of December, and I haven’t heard anything since, but with the season and everything I didn’t think much of it. However I now see that the agent have charged me £1100 on December 14th for ‘decoration’ - works about which I was never consulted, for which I never received a quote and which I certainly didn’t authorize their contractors to carry out. What I am trying to establish is, from a legal standpoint if nothing else, can they do this? Thanks very much.

  • Malgovert
    replied
    Thanks very much! I am on good terms with the tenant so will make contact to discuss.

    Leave a comment:


  • leaseholder64
    replied
    The tenant only has to make the property available, not themselves.

    Leave a comment:


  • jpkeates
    replied
    The tenant can't insist on the work being done outside normal hours.
    You can't make the tenant make themselves available, either.

    So a compromise is required.
    You can offer to attend in the tenant's absence (or for your agent to do that for you, assuming they will).
    Or you can wait until the tenant can be available.

    Leave a comment:


  • Malgovert
    replied
    Well would you believe it, it seems it was all a simple mistake. This turns out to be the last stage of a previous job agreed with the building management to be funded by the buildings insurance, and which had been erroneously charged to me during my usual property manager’s absence. The money will be refunded.

    so here’s a question- this means the other work is still to be done, and I have a contractor who has been in touch with the tenant and is ready to do the job during normal working hours, which to me seems reasonable. If the tenant is not happy with this and wants the work done outside normal working hours or at the weekend, is he / she in a position to insist that I get my guy to agree to do it, or find someone who will do it, or pass it over to the agent to take care of it? Or, since my guy’s proposal is not unreasonable, am I in a position to say that I am providing someone who can do the job on reasonable terms, and that if the tenant wants the work done he / she will have to make themselves available? Thanks.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lawcruncher
    replied
    Can we have confirmation that there is no provision in the agency agreement to the effect that the agent is authorised to do whatever is required to comply with the landlord's obligatons?

    Leave a comment:


  • jpkeates
    replied
    Originally posted by Malgovert View Post
    Is the contract not legally binding? Surely if one party or the other is in breach of contract it can be pursued - if only as a last resort - through the courts? Or - conversely - can I put myself in breach of contract and be assured that there is no possibility of legal action against me?
    A contract is legally binding (provided it's not invalid in some way, which is unlikely to be the case here).

    But breaching a contract isn't illegal.
    It simply puts the other party in the position of being able to either claim compensation or to ask a court to compel performance.

    In this case, your agent has not complied with the terms of the agreement and is (presumably) in breach.
    You would be entitled to compensation for any loss arising as compelling the agent to comply is not a possibility

    You've incurred a cost of £1100 and gained a newly decorated something, which would presumably have been necessary at some point.
    So the loss is probably somewhere below £1100, and should certainly include anything the agent earned as a consequence of their breach.

    If you breach the contract in some way, the agent would be entitled to ask for compensation or to compel performance in the same basic manner.

    Leave a comment:


  • theartfullodger
    replied
    I repeat.....
    Originally posted by theartfullodger View Post

    Follow agent complaints procedure: If not satisfied, then go to letting agent redress scheme - see...
    https://england.shelter.org.uk/housi...edress_schemes

    Leave a comment:


  • leaseholder64
    replied
    There is a limit to the compensation you could obtain. As you intended to do the work, anyway, the main thing you could claim for would be the difference between the quote from your contractor and the one through the agent. Although the agent may get commission, it is unlikely that you would be able to get the same discount, going directly to a contractor. Also, the 25% figure is an upper limit.

    The other option would be to get an injunction against further such breaches, but that is likely to be costly, and the easier remedy would be to change agents, although watch out for ant-poaching clauses, which may require you to change tenants, as well.

    Although you can't name and shame here, agents that ignore contracts, particularly national ones, will eventually get a bad reputation and find it difficult to get clients.

    Leave a comment:


  • Malgovert
    replied
    Is the contract not legally binding? Surely if one party or the other is in breach of contract it can be pursued - if only as a last resort - through the courts? Or - conversely - can I put myself in breach of contract and be assured that there is no possibility of legal action against me?

    Leave a comment:


  • jpkeates
    replied
    It's not a legal issue, it's a contractual issue.

    Legally, they're your agent and can take decisions and act on your behalf.
    Contractually, they're meant to do what they've agreed with you and not do what they've agreed not to do.

    From the sound of it, they've gone outside the agreement you have with them and could demand compensation for your loss as a consequence.
    Have they broken a law? Hard to see that they have.

    Leave a comment:


  • Malgovert
    replied
    Totally disagree. You don’t have to allow agents to help themselves to your money. Being ‘on the fiddle’ is not something we should simply accept, in London or anywhere else. My question was are they legally entitled to do this - if they are ‘on the fiddle’ then I would take that as a ‘no’...

    Leave a comment:


  • JK0
    replied
    I think this is something you have to accept sometimes on a property a long way away.

    Yeah, I know the agent is possibly on the fiddle, but London tenants are a fussy bunch.

    Leave a comment:


  • jpkeates
    replied
    I'd write to the manager of the agency and make a formal complaint and ask for the money to be reimbursed as it was not authorised.

    The (very) least the agent could do is send you the "referral fee" and "admin fee" they've made.

    Leave a comment:


  • theartfullodger
    replied
    When you asked them why they did this, for a copy of all invoices & to withdraw the charge, what did they say? (All in writing/email)

    Follow agent complaints procedure: If not satisfied, then go to letting agent redress scheme - see...
    https://england.shelter.org.uk/housi...edress_schemes

    Leave a comment:

Latest Activity

Collapse

  • Is letting agent negligent
    Elouise
    I currently rent a property in Northern Ireland. My previous tenants vacated my property due to none payment of rent. My agents went through the proper channels by serving notice. Unfortunately the previous tenant have taken some fixtures and fittings which belonged to me and damaged my property. The...
    09-10-2019, 08:34 AM
  • Reply to Is letting agent negligent
    DPT57
    That sounds like theft to me. You should report it to the police. I think you should also sack the agent who sounds like theyve been caught like a rabbit in the Tenant Fees Act headlights and in their confusion made the wrong call....
    20-10-2019, 08:28 AM
  • OpenRent vs. Visum
    John Duff
    Afternoon all.

    I (hopefully) will have a property to let in the next month or so.

    I listed it on Gumtree yesterday (as it's free). However, it has generated very little interest and I've only found it successful for finding migrant workers part subsidised by LHA in downtown...
    18-10-2019, 13:29 PM
  • Reply to OpenRent vs. Visum
    DPT57
    It has been for me. They offer you the option to do other things of course and I usually use their referencing but decline everything else. It hasn't been a hassle. The other thing worth mentioning is that it's relatively easy to get hold of them on the phone. I've had the odd complication with tenants...
    20-10-2019, 08:20 AM
  • Reply to OpenRent vs. Visum
    John Duff
    Good to know DPT57 but is the £29 option a truly no-strings advertise-only on Rightmove?
    18-10-2019, 19:22 PM
  • Reply to OpenRent vs. Visum
    DPT57
    I've used Openrent for the last few years for multiple properties. I agree that the 'rent now' option is a bid of an oddity and I don't know why they don't remove it from the site. I have to say though that in practice it has never been a problem for me as no-one has ever attempted that option with...
    18-10-2019, 16:18 PM
  • Letting Agents - Duty of Care
    kennyj52
    I'm wondering whether I have a case against my lettings agency in respect of the tenant they introduced to me who has turned out to have multiple outstanding CCJs, a prior eviction and is now 7 months in rent arrears. The lettings agency have been disappointing with the service they provided from the...
    09-12-2018, 22:35 PM
  • Reply to Letting Agents - Duty of Care
    kennyj52
    Thanks all for the advice and here is an update on my case against the agents. By the way, the tenant moved out voluntarily back in April, 2 days before the bailiffs arrived to enforce the eviction, so technically, I guess, she was "evicted"?

    Following the agents offer in June...
    17-10-2019, 21:15 PM
  • Am I within my rights to withhold estate agent fees due to their negligence?
    DP10
    The estate agent lost all my keys to the back garden. I've since taken two quotes and paid a reputable locksmith to replace entirely new lock system (e.g high security grill locks on ground floor garden flat).

    I never signed a contract with the estate agent but owe them 840 pounds for...
    15-10-2019, 10:35 AM
  • Reply to Am I within my rights to withhold estate agent fees due to their negligence?
    jpkeates
    I think there was definitely a contract, signing it isn't essential (unless there is a written contract with terms that say that it isn't valid until signed).

    You obviously have some kind of agreement, because the agent did things that show that they believed that you had retained their...
    17-10-2019, 08:57 AM
Working...
X