estate agents phone system query

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    estate agents phone system query

    Very bizarre question here.
    I normally withhold my mobile number - especially when calling estate agents as I don't want them constantly then hounding me.
    That was exactly the case when I rang one estate agent recently - the one that we all love to hate!
    Yet, the receptionist said that they could see my number. I hung up and double checked: my number was withheld.
    So how on earth does such an agent have the ability to see beyond a withheld number? Magic?

    Try 'phoning someone physically next to you & see what comes up...

    There could be several explanations..
    a) She can see a number but it ain;t yours (fault at her end/ her network provider/your network provider)
    2) She can see your number (fault to your end/your mobile network provider)
    iii) She's lying & can see no number...
    four) Your "I normally withhold.." wasn't on (no offence, perhaps your fault?)
    etc ...

    You are really asking "in a complex, multi-hardware, multi-software system with several different companies involved, something ain't working right: Could someone random tell me what ?"

    I also have no doubt that for the "Police systems" that the network operators use even withheld numbers are available, clear. i.e. the thought police are monitoring everything you do, say or enter....
    I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...


      I take you weren't phoning a freephone number. I'm not sure this is true in the UK, but in some countries freephone users can get the ANI (accounting number indication), which is not quite the same as CLI, but has the same value in simple cases.


        i was ringing a normal (London) office number 020... using my mobile.
        My number was definitely withheld. I triple checked/ rang home number and yes it says the number was withheld.
        So if my phone says its withheld how can an estate agents phone system "see" my number?


          For clarity I asked the agent what number they could see. They said the correct number; my mobile. They then asked if I could confirm who I was?


            Are you a customer of theirs? Or have you at least called them before and they may have your number on file?


              Not a client no. But am sure I called them in the past and am sure they will have number on file yes. But does that mean the withheld number gets overridden? It doesn't with other people I call...


                When you withhold your number it doesn't get sent, the space used to be filled with "withheld" sometimes.
                The recipient can't override it - it's possible an intelligence service (or google) might be able to work it out.

                If they knew who you were they might be looking at their customer record rather than the phone system.

                Or your phone or nertwork has a bug.
                When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
                Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


                  My suspicion is that they may be using a VoIP system that mis-implements presentation denied. In general the CLI is sent through the network and is only suppressed between the final network operator and their end user.

                  I think some mobile contracts also do not allow you to disable presentation of your caller ID.


                    A receptionist would not know the sound of my voice nor would they have any 'normal' way of knowing who I am. My mobile contract allows me to withhold my number. Their system clearly has had something done to it!! Interesting?


                    Latest Activity


                    • rip off contractor send out by letting agent.
                      Hopefully I can keep a long & boring story short....

                      My tenants reported an issue with a leaking washing machine while I was away on holiday, the letting agent got in contact and asked if I was happy to approve one of their contractors being sent out - at this point I agreed making...
                      12-12-2018, 17:50 PM
                    • Reply to rip off contractor send out by letting agent.
                      I would make a formal complaint to the agent. If they are using one of their approved contractors, they should be able to obtain further details of the work carried out by the contractor. You can ask the agent what steps they took to verify that the invoice was valid before authorising it for payment....
                      13-12-2018, 20:58 PM
                    • Reply to rip off contractor send out by letting agent.
                      Who is charging you for the work?

                      If it's the letting agent charging you having paid the plumber already, dispute the invoice from the letting agent.
                      I appreciate that they've probably deducted the cost from the rent that they pass on, but that's not the end of the issue.
                      13-12-2018, 09:56 AM
                    • Reply to rip off contractor send out by letting agent.
                      Manage the property yourself. We do this with ours. Providing you have your own tradesmen on whom you can call, being 2000 miles away isn't a problem.
                      13-12-2018, 00:52 AM
                    • Reply to rip off contractor send out by letting agent.
                      My gut feeling is that this could have happened with pretty much every letting agent? So better the devil you know! I'd also prefer to deal with this as an individual issue with the current agent, but I've got literally no knowledge of any best practices for letting agents managing 3rd part contr...
                      12-12-2018, 19:35 PM
                    • Reply to rip off contractor send out by letting agent.
                      I think I'd be finding a new letting agent in future.
                      12-12-2018, 18:02 PM
                    • Changing agents and paperwork
                      Hi all,

                      I had some properties with an agency who sold out to another company. I was approached by two of the staff of the old company who have set up their own business in competition.

                      Because I've had a good relationship with the two of them and I have no obligation to the...
                      11-12-2018, 08:33 AM
                    • Reply to Changing agents and paperwork
                      Think they'll magically find the documents went missing before they took over.

                      You may have serious problems trying to evict tenant without paperwork, In your shoes I'd offer tenant a new tenancy, plus all paperwork, at a slightly reduced rent (so they are keen to sign...): So everything...
                      12-12-2018, 15:50 PM
                    • Reply to Changing agents and paperwork
                      Ask them if they have reported the data breach to the ICO. Under new GDPR, they are supposed to notify the ICO within 72 hours.

                      Since it's your data they've lost, tell them you'll also report the incident to the ICO. They'll probably magically reappear.
                      12-12-2018, 14:35 PM
                    • Estate agent not giving rent contracts
                      He seems to be something of a strange estate agent because he is refusing to give us the rental contracts for two different sets of tenants he found for us for two different properties. One lot moved in during February 2018 and the other lot during June 2018. I can't understand his motives for being...
                      05-11-2018, 19:44 PM