Troublesome ex-tenant's accident claim one year later

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Troublesome ex-tenant's accident claim one year later

    My last, and I hope final, tenants vacated my property in May. At their request I allowed them to vacate one month early. They were a nightmare during the entire tenancy and did all sorts of things in the property without first obtaining permission. For example they changed wall lights and in one place removed the light completely, took down all curtain rails and blinds, left holes everywhere, removed plants from the garden, put the dishwasher in the garage, left the garden in a mess etc. All this was carried out without obtaining any permission. I was notified about storm damage but when the insurance assessor arrived, they told his it was not damaged in the storm so the insurance refused to pay out.

    Consequently a claim was put in for the retention of the deposit and some very reasonable extra costs added to it. During the entire tenancy I rarely received the full rental as complaints piled in. I believe the following claim from them is tit for tat.

    When they moved in there were two sets of fitted wardrobes in one of the bedrooms. I received a request from the letting agent for them to move one set to the dressing room. I agreed to this. I then had another request to dismantle the other set. Thia I refused as I wanted to keep them. Several weeks later I discovered that they had ignored my instructions and had dismantled them and thrown them away at the tip. No request was ever received to say that they were in a poor condition or was I ever notified that the tenant had received a minor injury while carrying out the dismantling.

    I have now received a completely untruthfull claim by the tenant saying that they had requested the wardrobes to be removed, they had not been and one of the wardrobes collapsed, landed on her foot and an injury was sustained. There follows a long list of failures on my part, which of course are not true either.

    In my defence I have emails to and from the letting agent and a photo of the wardrobe set taken during an inspection less than a month before.

    All this occurred almost a year ago.

    How will my insurance company handle this? What do I do first? Help please!

    Courts have this unusual liking for a little thing called evidence. Evidence is provided by both sides. Evidence includes such things as proof that they had asked you, and it was declined/accepted. Proof that an injury happened and what was being done to cause the injury, as well as proof that the injury caused a financial loss, or quantifiable pain and distress. The court would want to know why you were never informed of this 'injury' beforehand, and why is it relevant now.
    If you feel confident that you carried out your duties correctly, and can evidence (or convince the Judge) that you were reasonable and fair, then you should be confident in attending court. Ex-tenants frequently stamp their feet, usually because they've dug themselves a financial hole (probably arrears with the new landlord so facing eviction) therefore they hunt around for some other poor mug who'll cough up some money to bail them out.
    I may be a housing professional but my views, thoughts, opinions, advice, criticisms or otherwise on this board are mine and are not representative of my company, colleagues, managers. I am here as an independent human being who simply wants to learn new stuff, share ideas and interact with like minded people.


      Troublesome ex-tenant's accident claim one year later

      Thank you very much Darth Wookie for your very prompt and useful reply. I am about to contact my insurance company.


        Almost regardless of what this might cost me in time or money I would not agree to their request.

        I would either not reply at all or refer them to "Arkell v Pressdram"..

        I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...


          Thank you and I will certainly look up your link. That is exactly how I feel: incandescent with anger! Thanks again Patricia118



            Don't expect the insurance company to cover you for malicious or wanton damage.

            If tenants destroyed your property, on purpose, it's not an insurance claim, unless your "landlord" insurance covers you for malicious and wanton damage.


              Loved it Artful - gave me a giggle! I will certainly use that one in the future
              Unshackled by the chains of idle vanity, A modest manatee, that's me


                I am of the old generation Artful, so not a word I have ever used in my life, but it certainly made me chuckle too. Thanks.

                Thanks to everyone else too.


                Latest Activity


                • A slightly more complicated water damage issue

                  I own and am the landlord of a flat. The flat below is landlord owned and has tenants, the flat below them is owner occupied

                  There has been an issue with a leak from the flat below mine into the flat below his, it has caused damage to the bathrooms in both flats....
                  20-03-2019, 21:10 PM
                • Reply to A slightly more complicated water damage issue
                  If its a leak from radiator and went though 2 flats and is visable im sure you will have noticed, you would have had to top boiler up and bleed radiators. Hes trying it on already said hasn't got insurance so hes blaming you
                  21-03-2019, 18:43 PM
                • Reply to A slightly more complicated water damage issue
                  Thanks very much, I'm going round to have a look this evening, and I'll be calling a plumber tomorrow and speaking to the insurance company once I've spoken to the plumber

                  the flat below and is already talking about who pays and the flat below them is talking about liability already....
                  21-03-2019, 17:10 PM
                • Reply to A slightly more complicated water damage issue
                  There's no default liability for a leak.
                  Leaks happen, and unless there's been either negligence or a deliberate act to cause the leak, the question of liability doesn't arise.
                  And as there isn't really anything anyone can do to "maintain" pipework, negligence is a bit of a stretch....
                  21-03-2019, 14:34 PM
                • Reply to A slightly more complicated water damage issue
                  You can get a leak from a bedroom if the bedroom has a radiator. I have experience of a leaking central heating pipe under floorboards causing damage to a room below. It was a real pain to find as at first it appeared to be penetrating damp. You can also get leaks running a fair way under floorboards...
                  21-03-2019, 10:29 AM
                • Airbnb Insurance cover.
                  I rent a cottage. My tenant has asked to use a room for Airbnb for holiday lets.. My insurer has said it will negate the Cover they provide..They will cover for a lodger but not for Airbnb.. I rang another Insurer who provide cover but only if Airbnb is being provided within where the homeowner lives....
                  20-03-2019, 16:31 PM
                • Reply to Airbnb Insurance cover.
                  Airbnb not a problem but as the tenant want to arrange it, it falls under the "sub-letting" category which makes most insurers run a mile. Think you will have trouble getting the cover you need, coupled with other potential issues as per above post, I think this is more hassle than it's w...
                  21-03-2019, 10:26 AM
                • Reply to A slightly more complicated water damage issue
                  I would just relay everything in your post to your landlord insurer. I do not know the extent of coverage on your insurance policy but things that will help are:

                  "Trace and Access" cover which would cover the locating and repairing of the leak
                  "Property Owners Liability"...
                  21-03-2019, 09:58 AM
                • Insrance cover for leaseholder
                  Hello, I inherited a
                  flat in a typical terraced street, I also am the leaseholder for the upstairs flat, I receive no benefit for this I think the term is peppercorn lease. I have asked D Line for a quote on the flat I own and they have quoted me for this but they said I have to have cover...
                  20-03-2019, 14:51 PM
                • Reply to Insrance cover for leaseholder
                  Just to clarify. If the lease doesn't make anyone responsible for arranging the insurance, any party to it can go to the tribunal to force a change, but if it simply leaves the freeholder responsible for paying, you are likely to need unanimous agreement to change it.
                  20-03-2019, 22:17 PM