Insurance claim

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Insurance claim

    Hi All, my first post.
    After tenant caused a small kitchen fire, I've replaced the entire kitchen. Insurers are covering upper units, decoration etc. but state they will not pay for lower kitchen units as they were not damaged in fire. Any thoughts on how to proceed?

    #2
    Hmm. I guess you are up against 'betterment' provisions, the same as if you were making deposit deductions.

    Presumably you will now not have to replace the kitchen as soon as you would have previously. Therefore, don't the insurers have a point in saying that they will only pay for a proportion of the cost?

    Comment


      #3
      Insurance is to return you to the same financial position after an insured incident - not to give you a whole new kitchen. If a fire has only damaged the upper units then that is all they are required to replace. Normally an insurer will do the best they can to match the new units to the old ones but it seems you have already gone and replaced the whole kitchen so this is now not an option.

      All you can do now is give the insurer the invoice and expect a percentage of the total bill paid. Another thing worth bearing in mind is that they will only pay for the new value of the damaged units. This means that if the previous kitchen was £2000 new and half of it was damaged then they will pay out £1000 regardless of the value of the new kitchen you have just installed. Obviously any payout will be less the excess on the policy.
      Steve Smith - Company Director at a leading Landlord Insurance broker with 20+ years experience in the industry
      LandlordZONE Verified Poster and Topic Expert for Landlords Insurance since 2009
      See my profile for contact details

      Comment


        #4
        Many thanks for the swift and knowledgeable responses.

        I appreciate JKO's and ashburton's comments on why improving the property is not the remit of the insurers!

        After the fire, I attempted to match the units; this was not possible and the insurers were notified that the whole kitchen would need replacing. If I had not fitted a new kitchen the rental loss resulting from the mis-matched kitchen would have left me financially worse off. Whilst an insurance claim should not result in the improvement of a property, neither should it leave the insured financially worse off and I don't consider this to be a valid interpretation of the claim.

        All comments gratefully received!

        Comment


          #5
          If just the top units were replaced being matched as closely as they could, how much would it realistically affect your rental income? Putting a figure on this would be very difficult. If I was living in a property charging me £800p/m and then half of my kitchen was replaced which didn't match but was new, I think I would have no grounds to ask to pay less rent but this is just my own personal opinion.

          The other way to look at this is if the insurer paid for the whole kitchen then you would be in a financially better position as your property would be worth more and you would certainly be entitled to charge more rent. Insurance is not for making a profit on so this makes this situation quite tricky.

          I think your only solution is to speak to the insurance company and argue your point (paragraph 1) while they argue there point (paragraph 2) and come to some compromise in the costs which you are both happy with.
          Steve Smith - Company Director at a leading Landlord Insurance broker with 20+ years experience in the industry
          LandlordZONE Verified Poster and Topic Expert for Landlords Insurance since 2009
          See my profile for contact details

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by 7skypilot View Post
            If I had not fitted a new kitchen the rental loss resulting from the mis-matched kitchen would have left me financially worse off.
            That's a bold claim: You're saying that unless units matches exactly the achievable rent will be reduced, which is far from obvious.
            I think this is the key e.g. if attempting to have the tenant pay for anything related to lower units (upper bound being residual value of old units)

            I guess that having the lower and higher units not matching in a pleasant way is a valid decoration idea, btw. It's all about taste, so difficult to quantify.

            Comment


              #7
              Thanks to all for your comments.
              I guess the 'rental loss' is a bit of a red herring. I'll be pursuing the insurers for the cost of reinstating the kitchen and will try to let you know the result.

              Comment


                #8
                It took me 6 years to realise not all the kitchen units matched exactly!

                Comment


                  #9
                  Next time you could try for frosted or etched glass doors, which can be useful here for wall cupboards if you need to non-match.

                  Insurer should be happy if they cost the same or you pay the difference.

                  ML
                  Refer Mad Regulators to Arkell vs Pressdram.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Hi- one problem is that you could go out and purchase an exact replacement from the manufacturer and still have the kitchen look mismatched due to damage to existing units from UV or simply manufacturing dilot differences (common issue when tiling).

                    The only thing you can do is to seek out an independant adjustor to assess the situation and fight the insurance company on your behalf.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      A friend's rental flat above a restaurant had his entire contents replaced, (including kitchen units,) after a fire in the property below. There was no burn damage to anything in his flat but the smoke damage, (which was deemed carcinogenic,) was enough to cause replacement of everything by the insurance company. I saw the flat after the fire and could only just about smell the smoke damage. There was very little to see in the way of visible damage.

                      Comment

                      Latest Activity

                      Collapse

                      • Moving Costs Building Insurance
                        Dorisamelia
                        I am a leaseholder and I have suffered 5 water leaks in the period of 6 months from the flat above mine. My property is a large ( 1250 sq.ft.) studio. The management company of the block is also the Freeholder and the leaseholder of the offending flat above. A claim on the block building insurance,...
                        09-04-2019, 22:11 PM
                      • Reply to Moving Costs Building Insurance
                        Dorisamelia
                        Thank you all for your comments. Much appreciated. I am not having much success with the Local Council Private Housing dept. Apparently they only deal with Tenants in privately rented homes and not owner/ occupiers! I could pursue the local Magistrates Court...... but I have just been made aware of...
                        19-04-2019, 19:22 PM
                      • Reply to Moving Costs Building Insurance
                        Gordon999
                        If you did not receive a summary of the insured cover within 30 days, it becomes a criminal offence and you can report the criminal offence to the Housing Officer at your Local Council for prosecution or file a complaint yourself at your local Magistrates Court ( speak to the Court Manager who...
                        12-04-2019, 04:53 AM
                      • Reply to Moving Costs Building Insurance
                        Dorisamelia
                        Thank you JKO - Service charge demands are in order; the paperwork is correct. I have written to the management company yesterday and advised them that since the insurance will not pay for moving costs and this expense has not been covered in the quote, I will remain in residence and the builder, during...
                        11-04-2019, 10:03 AM
                      • Reply to Moving Costs Building Insurance
                        JK0
                        Yeah, sounds fair enough to me.

                        BTW, how are they demanding service charge, ground rent & insurance monies? Check everything comes with correct paperwork, as this might give you some leverage, if they don't pay up for your losses.
                        10-04-2019, 18:09 PM
                      • Reply to Moving Costs Building Insurance
                        Dorisamelia
                        I sent a written request by " registered post " for a copy of summary insurance policy just after the last flood. No reply from them! I have damage to my contents but unfortunately no contents insurance. I intend to pursue the matter via the courts and prove negligence. I am trying to get...
                        10-04-2019, 11:00 AM
                      • Reply to Moving Costs Building Insurance
                        Gordon999
                        Send a written request by "registered post" to request a "summary of insured cover for your building" and you should get the reply within 21 days or 30 days or failing this it becomes a criminal offence.
                        09-04-2019, 22:56 PM
                      • Reply to Moving Costs Building Insurance
                        JK0
                        Don't you even know the name of the insurer? If you know that, I'd have thought they could inform you of the cover.

                        Failing that, I'd book into a travel lodge, for the minimum time and then sue freeholder for the cost.

                        Have you any damaged contents? Have you contents insur...
                        09-04-2019, 22:19 PM
                      • Leak damage from property above; Does the landlord pay for damage to my property?
                        Bassodone
                        Hi
                        The flat above my flat has had various leaks over the years and I had not seen any damage to my property below. However just recently there was a large leak from their bathroom, which caused water damage to walls, plaster and painting, Quite a lot of water entered the property. It has taken...
                        02-04-2019, 20:38 PM
                      • Reply to Leak damage from property above; Does the landlord pay for damage to my property?
                        Hudson01
                        Wow..... seems harsh but it shows the importance of having good and up to date insurance.
                        04-04-2019, 19:45 PM
                      Working...
                      X