Collective enfranchisement - disagreement over loft conversion

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Collective enfranchisement - disagreement over loft conversion

    Hi everyone

    I wonder whether anyone can help. I live in a Victorian house which is split into three flats. I own the top one and would like to do a loft conversion (the loft is not demised to me). I have agreed with one other leaseholder that we'll buy the freehold together, I'll pay extra in the process and then do the conversion. The issue is the other (remaining) leaseholder doesn't agree with the terms (they don't want me to convert at all, ever) but they do want to buy the freehold (sharing the cost equally). I don't want us to share the cost equally because I'll never be able to do the conversion if I need the militant leaseholder to agree.

    Can anyone think of a potential way forward?


    Will your flat be paying for all the roof repairs in future? I'd have thought that would swing it for the militant guy, if he did not realise that.


      I shall refer to the original poster as OP; the leaseholder in agreement with loft conversion as A; and the leaseholder objecting as B.

      There are separate transactions here: the purchase of the freehold via an RMC; and the OP, in capacity as leaseholder, applying to the RMC for consent to acquire and convert the loft.

      The RMC’s Articles should include arrangements in relation to managing consents and any payments. (Notwithstanding, the RMC cannot override the lease or statutory legislation in respect of leaseholders’ rights and obligations). The Articles will also cover voting rights and the quorum required. That being the case it is not necessary (or arguably fair) to exclude B from the enfranchisement process. It is also possible to appoint additional directors perhaps assisting a more objective rationale behind decision making. Notably, the OP will probably not be able to vote re loft as there will be a conflict of interest.

      OP could proceed to issue s13 notice with A excluding B. However, this assumes A’s agreement and will not assist neighbourly relationships or management of building going forward. There is also nothing to stop B changing their mind about consent post-enfranchisement.

      I suggest all participants should pay the same and acquire equal shares of the RMC. The OP should then apply for consent via the RMC. Assuming consent the payment agreed should be made to the RMC ultimately to benefit shareholders which will include the OP.

      This might all be academic as enfranchisement might not proceed and/or the price for the loft might be too high; or planning consent might not be obtained.

      I appreciate we do not have all of the information so I make a number of assumptions above. It is just food for thought not designed to be comprehensive and is only an opinion. In the situation, it is likely a solicitor will be involved and will provide advice to clarify matters in more definitive terms.


        Originally posted by smitchell View Post
        (the loft is not demised to me)
        Are you sure?

        Please read this thread:


        Latest Activity


        • Freehold valuation
          Trying to find somebody to carry out the freehold valuation.

          So far no luck, any recommendations?
          11-07-2019, 13:58 PM
        • Reply to Freehold valuation
          Hi Anna

          You could try searching for desktop valuations of freehold. This service would be adequate for valuation purposes though not suitable re condition which would require a site survey. Nevertheless, speak with a company offering desktop valuations and ask them if condition impacts...
          13-07-2019, 12:53 PM
        • Reply to Freehold valuation
          Thank you for the advice. We basically know the price range of the freehold, it is more to validate it as an asset and to see if the value of it will be affected by actual state of the property.
          13-07-2019, 11:32 AM
        • Reply to Freehold valuation
          May I ask why you need the valuation?

          TRY THIS: telephone a solicitor that deals with enfranchisement (google 'enfranchisement solicitor' and put in your postcode). Call them and ask if they can recommend a surveyor specializing in valuing freeholds....
          12-07-2019, 17:06 PM
        • Reply to Freehold valuation
          There are lots of people who do valuations. As soon as you mention freehold - we will come back to you and they are still coming back.

          I'm really wondering if it is really worth to have it valued....
          12-07-2019, 15:14 PM
        • Reply to Freehold valuation
          I am surprised but you will just have to google or check online directories for surveyors in your area. Sorry, I cannot be of more help but there are plenty of surveyors offering freehold valuations.
          12-07-2019, 11:13 AM
        • House has two leases, can I buy the freehold or head lease?!
          I am in an area of the country where the council retains the freehold on developments - ostensibly to avoid fragmentation of estates. My developer owned the head lease when I bought the property, and has since sold it to a leasehold management company. The head lease is a peppercorn rent to the council...
          09-07-2019, 09:10 AM
        • Reply to House has two leases, can I buy the freehold or head lease?!
          We enfranchised our freehold at which point the head lease and our own lease were merged into our new freehold title....
          11-07-2019, 21:29 PM
        • Reply to Freehold valuation
          I did, tried several people - 0 reply.
          11-07-2019, 19:31 PM
        • Reply to Freehold valuation
          Recommendations are against forum rules.

          Check the RICs website. Scroll down to the bottom of the page and select the 'Find a Surveyor' link. Enter your postcode to populate the page with a list of surveyors near you.
          11-07-2019, 19:25 PM