Collective enfranchisement - disagreement over loft conversion

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Collective enfranchisement - disagreement over loft conversion

    Hi everyone

    I wonder whether anyone can help. I live in a Victorian house which is split into three flats. I own the top one and would like to do a loft conversion (the loft is not demised to me). I have agreed with one other leaseholder that we'll buy the freehold together, I'll pay extra in the process and then do the conversion. The issue is the other (remaining) leaseholder doesn't agree with the terms (they don't want me to convert at all, ever) but they do want to buy the freehold (sharing the cost equally). I don't want us to share the cost equally because I'll never be able to do the conversion if I need the militant leaseholder to agree.

    Can anyone think of a potential way forward?

    Sally




    #2
    Will your flat be paying for all the roof repairs in future? I'd have thought that would swing it for the militant guy, if he did not realise that.

    Comment


      #3
      I shall refer to the original poster as OP; the leaseholder in agreement with loft conversion as A; and the leaseholder objecting as B.

      There are separate transactions here: the purchase of the freehold via an RMC; and the OP, in capacity as leaseholder, applying to the RMC for consent to acquire and convert the loft.

      The RMC’s Articles should include arrangements in relation to managing consents and any payments. (Notwithstanding, the RMC cannot override the lease or statutory legislation in respect of leaseholders’ rights and obligations). The Articles will also cover voting rights and the quorum required. That being the case it is not necessary (or arguably fair) to exclude B from the enfranchisement process. It is also possible to appoint additional directors perhaps assisting a more objective rationale behind decision making. Notably, the OP will probably not be able to vote re loft as there will be a conflict of interest.

      OP could proceed to issue s13 notice with A excluding B. However, this assumes A’s agreement and will not assist neighbourly relationships or management of building going forward. There is also nothing to stop B changing their mind about consent post-enfranchisement.

      I suggest all participants should pay the same and acquire equal shares of the RMC. The OP should then apply for consent via the RMC. Assuming consent the payment agreed should be made to the RMC ultimately to benefit shareholders which will include the OP.

      This might all be academic as enfranchisement might not proceed and/or the price for the loft might be too high; or planning consent might not be obtained.

      I appreciate we do not have all of the information so I make a number of assumptions above. It is just food for thought not designed to be comprehensive and is only an opinion. In the situation, it is likely a solicitor will be involved and will provide advice to clarify matters in more definitive terms.


      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by smitchell View Post
        (the loft is not demised to me)
        Are you sure?

        Please read this thread:https://forums.landlordzone.co.uk/fo...-in-the-lease=



        Comment

        Latest Activity

        Collapse

        • Purchase of freehold
          by Drewcole
          Hi All,

          I own a 2 bed ground floor flat in a converted Victorian house (2 flats in total) that i have a long lease of 167yrs. I currently pay a ground rent of £160, a service charge of £400 and a insurance premium of £800!

          I have spoken to the owner of the flat above and...
          10-08-2020, 15:16 PM
        • Reply to Purchase of freehold
          by Drewcole
          Hi, I thought it was a little high considering its two flat with a tiny hallway shared that hasn't been maintained since I've owned.

          I guess I can only try, if I do nothing then I'm letting them get away with over charging on the insurance. £1500 for insurance for the two flats seems...
          11-08-2020, 11:40 AM
        • Buying house with sitting tenant
          by carolem
          Residential house for sale with tenant holding over. AST for 6 months granted by letting agents of current owner in November 2019. Since it expired tenant been holding over and paying rent etc. As a potential purchaser who wants to buy it as investment with tenant in situ are there any issues for me...
          07-08-2020, 13:20 PM
        • Reply to Buying house with sitting tenant
          by Gordon999
          Yes, you should arrange for new AST rental agreement because the last one is in the previous owner's name and no longer valid. You have no legal right to hold the tenants deposit without AST agreement. .
          11-08-2020, 10:37 AM
        • Reply to Purchase of freehold
          by Gordon999
          If you find alternative companies are quoting much lower insurance premium, you can ask the current broker to declare how much commission has been paid and then you consider making application to FTT for judgement on the reasonable cost of the buildings insurance. ,

          I think your current...
          11-08-2020, 09:17 AM
        • Reply to Purchase of freehold
          by Drewcole
          Thanks for the replies, so I've had a quick look online to. See how long the lease is on the other flat, she seems to have about 63yrs remaining so the cost to try a purchase the freehold myself is a no go.

          I will write and request the insurance info and try and go down that route. Is there...
          11-08-2020, 07:12 AM
        • Reply to Purchase of freehold
          by Gordon999
          It requires both flats in a building with 2 flats ) to participate in compulsory freehold purchase. See last sentence in section 2 in the free guide.

          https://www.lease-advice.org/advice-...tting-started/

          If the buildings insurance is £800 per flat, you are probably...
          10-08-2020, 18:00 PM
        • Reply to Purchase of freehold
          by Anna1985
          I would check how long is downstairs lease.
          and then would run the estimated costs freehold on lease calculator.
          And go from there.
          10-08-2020, 17:52 PM
        • Documentation for renovations on share of freehold flat
          by Basecamp
          We are a first floor flat, share of freehold with the ground floor flat. We both have a 999 year lease. In 2014 we did a loft conversion. We had a party wall agreement with the other share of freeholder flat, planning permission and it has all been signed off by building control. However, should we...
          06-08-2020, 10:45 AM
        • Reply to Documentation for renovations on share of freehold flat
          by Basecamp
          Thank you for your responses. We will consult w lawyer to have the Deed updated with the new floor plan....
          08-08-2020, 09:16 AM
        Working...
        X