Can a long term lease ever be quashed if circumstances alter?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Can a long term lease ever be quashed if circumstances alter?

    I am a director of my golf club. We have a long term lease with the landowner. The annual rent was made up of a fixed amount plus a percentage of turnover. This has totalled up to £70k per annum. The golf course went through some difficult times and five years ago a deal was reached whereby we paid a reduced rent for a period of time. Both parties had a 12 month break clause inserted in the five year amendment. We are currently in the final year of the five year agreement and our rent is now £35k for this year. This is going to be a struggle for us to pay. When the five year agreement comes to an end the landlord is insisting we go back to the original terms of the lease with no obligation to negotiate on the rent we pay. The golf industry has gone through many changes over the intervening period with membership declining and general participation in the sport declining too. Is there any precedent for having the original lease quashed, forcing our landlords to negotiate a new lease on more realistic terms?

    Is the lease within the ?
    Do you think the landlord may have other potential tenant lined up ?


      Unless the terms of the tenancy allow it, a tenant cannot bring a lease to an end because of a change of circumstances. It looks like your only options are to exercise the break clause or pay the increased rent.


      Latest Activity


      • Should I prepare myself
        My wife got a text from our T who rents the shop below our flat (she handles the commercial property) and he was telling her about his tales of woe.

        Basically he fell for a scam thinking it was HMRC and he lost 20k. He paid his rent last week for this up and coming quarter so rent isn't...
        18-10-2019, 08:52 AM
      • Reply to Should I prepare myself
        evicting a commercial tenant is entirely different to the regime in evicting residential tenants. My advice is to offer the tenant to pay under a weekly standing order; a quarter's rent in advance can be quite difficult to find. If you are going for possession it must be the case that nothing has been...
        18-10-2019, 14:39 PM
      • Eliminate business rates D1 class
        I have an existing D1 class building that has the windows boarded due to vandalism. To eliminate business rates I understand that the property must be in use. Art galleries would have zero business rates based on my circumstances and the business rates band. I'm wondering whether it is feasible to create...
        17-10-2019, 13:58 PM
      • Mines and minerals
        I hold the rights to both 'mines and minerals,, including coal (now irrelevant of course) but ironstone and all other minerals, albeit entry to the surface not allowed. The site is 31 acres but a developer plans to build at least 50 houses on part of the land. In view of the fact that I apparently own...
        11-10-2019, 14:42 PM
      • Reply to Mines and minerals
        Many thanks for all the comments, but it is my fault for not making it clear that I was concerned about the value, if any, to me. The land is only part of a vast scheme involving thousands of houses in a joint local authority/ private developer plan. Virtually the whole part of 'my' site is over shallow...
        16-10-2019, 21:45 PM
      • Lease renewal aga
        Hi I'm in the process of lease assignment with a aga.

        The lease will be due for renewal after 1 year. My question is will my aga stop once the lease is renewed?...
        13-10-2019, 17:34 PM
      • Reply to Lease renewal aga
        "Hi I'm in the process of lease assignment with a aga. The lease will be due for renewal after 1 year. My question is will my aga stop once the lease is renewed?"

        It is not clear from your op that you are the existing tenant. I read the op to mean that you are to become the tenant...
        16-10-2019, 08:46 AM
      • Urgent advice needed on security of tenure
        I am renting an office unit and need advice regarding security of tenure and the option of applying to court to renew a tenancy. The situation is as follows:

        I signed a 1 year lease for the unit which had a clause excluding security of tenure. This came up on 1st Oct but unfortunately...
        16-10-2019, 07:58 AM
      • Reply to Lease renewal aga
        I'm slightly confused sorry, so as the existing tenant I assign my lease to a new tenant with landlords consent and all referencing and aga and deposit(from new tenant).

        1 year after I have assigned the lease the lease term has expired assuming the now new tenant signs a new lease with...
        15-10-2019, 19:11 PM
      • New landlord informs me I must sign new contract & double door access to be removed
        samuel smith
        My business (joinery workshop) lease 'Landlord and Tenants Act 1954 for 6 years) is being purchased by my landlords daughter, who has told me I must sign a new lease and that vehicular access and double doors will no longer be available, which will make my business unworkable. What can I do?
        15-10-2019, 12:10 PM