Accident caused by faulty mechanism in council garage

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Accident caused by faulty mechanism in council garage

    I have rented a council garage for ten years. The garages, themselves are more than 50 years old and the Council's policy is that they do not service the Garage, but only repair when a fault is reported. I recently opened my Garage door and the mechanism broke causing the Garage door to collapse on top of my car. I reported this to the council immediately and claimed for damages. The Council deny liability on the grounds that I had a duty to report any fault with the Garage and that the accident was due to wear and tear. There had been no previous indication that anything was wrong with the mechanism. I have used the council complaints procedure but have had no satisfaction. Does anybody know what my legal rights are please?

    What does the tenancy agreement say about reporting problems, if anything?

    Nothing to stop you suing council (LBA then small claims): .You may or may not win.
    I am legally unqualified: If you need to rely on advice check it with a suitable authority - eg a solicitor specialising in landlord/tenant law...


      Seems to me that you would need to prove that the council accepted faulty work 50 years ago, and the expected life of the mechanism is much more than that.


        Just musing what would happen if one of my tenants had their car damaged by one of my garage mechanisms falling on it...

        I suspect either I or my insurers would be paying a big bill.


          The council's policy sounds like a problem.
          They're relying on their customers to notify them of something that needs attention, and hoping that the first indication of something going wrong is not catastrophic.

          You'd expect some kind of routine inspection, just to reduce the instance of things like this happening.
          Can't expect consumers to be expert in garage mechanisms.
          When I post, I am expressing an opinion - feel free to disagree, I have been wrong before.
          Please don't act on my suggestions without checking with a grown-up (ideally some kind of expert).


            I wouldn't expect an owner occupier to contract out routine inspecitons.


            Latest Activity


            • Landlord opening my cafe
              Good morning

              My commercial landlord is opening my cafe when I'm not there without my consent, he has done this whilst I was on holiday and when I am closed. He is using my stock to sell for his own benefit and is treating me very unfairly. He is Also keeps telling me that he is going to...
              19-02-2018, 11:35 AM
            • Short Term Lease
              Tenant has exercised break clause for current lease (which is excluded from LTA 1954) and it is due to end in April.

              Tenant has since stated they would like to remain for a further 4month term.

              What happens if tenant remains in occupation, would this become a periodic tenancy...
              13-02-2018, 10:43 AM
            • Reply to Short Term Lease
              In terms of documenting this what would be required? is a simple letter outlining terms sufficient?

              And what notice period would the tenant/landlord have to provide to quit?
              18-02-2018, 20:36 PM
            • Commercial buy to let mortgage
              Evening everyone,

              I have just signed up here looking for some advice.

              I have previously dabbled with property but on a buy/sell basis however in the next month or so I am looking to start a rental portfolio. The area I plan on buying is a town I know well, I have friends/family...
              26-12-2017, 23:41 PM
            • Reply to Commercial buy to let mortgage
              I've contacted Charleston Financial Services and B2B Mortgages before and both were very helpful in giving advise and finding suitable lenders....
              16-02-2018, 23:11 PM
            • Law Society lease - "out of the Act"
              Is there any problem in granting a law society lease out of the act?

              (after signing the statutory declaration by a solicitor)...
              07-02-2018, 17:10 PM
            • Reply to Law Society lease - "out of the Act"
              I'm assuming the OP meant the 1954 Landlord and Tenant Act but the question needs to be clarified to receive proper response. My take on anything that involves a contract is to get a solicitor to make sure everything is done correctly. If you have any uncertainty on the wording of a document it's worth...
              16-02-2018, 23:03 PM
            • Reply to Short Term Lease
              My view. Contracted out and served break. Lease ends on break date. Tenant is then in under new agreement - 54 protection will then be an issue unless -

              • where the term of the lease is for 6 months or less (unless the lease allows for an extension); or
              • where the tenant’s...
              16-02-2018, 21:05 PM
            • Reply to Short Term Lease

              anyone able to offer any suggestions?...
              16-02-2018, 14:09 PM
            • Garage Rental Advice
              I have rented a garage for the past 5 years and have been paying the same monthly amount by standing order. Last week I received a phone call asking me what I was going to do about the arrears on my account. When questioned I was informed that the rental amount had increased three times in the last...
              14-02-2018, 18:51 PM