Can a landlord make a tenant pay for extension regularisation costs?

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Can a landlord make a tenant pay for extension regularisation costs?

    My landlord has a commercial property with 3 floors. Ground floor is leased to us. The 1st floor has an extension which doesnt have building regulations. This extension has been in place for 10 years. We want regularisation of the extension. However stupidly my partner took lease out without survey and we have 50% responsibility for repair costs etc. Is it correct to assume that we will have to pay 50% of costs for any works relating to regularisation? Including possible costs relating to knocking it down?

    thank you.

    #2
    I don't think ll would have a leg to stand on if it came to court. Just don't pay.

    Comment


      #3
      Thank you for responding. That was my initial common sense thought but someone with legal background suggested that since its a full repair lease and when combined with the fact that we didnt do survey etc (therefore buyer beware) it makes us part liable for any possible costs as the unregulated works have an impact on the building ie structure etc. Since it would be like any other repair that we may be asked to contribute to.

      Comment


        #4
        I think this is something only a judge would be able to answer. If you are asked for the money, tell landlord you will wait for a judge to answer it. (It's landlord who has to sue you. Not that you have to sue him.)

        Comment


          #5
          Thank you again

          Comment

          Latest Activity

          Collapse

          • Rent review issue
            Charlie16
            I have a tenant on a lease with a five year term on a commercial property. The lease specified a rent review after 2,3 and 4 years. The lease also specified that the rent review should be determined by the RPI index and it specifies the mechanism for doing this. I duly calculated the rent review on...
            06-01-2019, 00:25 AM
          • Reply to Rent review issue
            Lawcruncher
            What does he mean by that? Is he saying that if the tenant does not like the result obtained by the formula or considers an incorrect calculation has been made that the tenant can call in a third party? That is not what an RPI clause should do. What it should do is obviate the need for negotiation and...
            20-01-2019, 12:48 PM
          • Reply to Rent review issue
            Charlie16
            My solicitor responded and he agrees that appointment of surveyor is what should happen if no agreement can be found. Funnily enough he hasn’t said the whole clause is badly drafted but then I never expected them to do so as they drew it up. Next steps are to make the tenant an offer to settle and...
            20-01-2019, 10:43 AM
          • Reply to Rent review issue
            Lawcruncher
            A properly drafted RPI rent increase clause should have two elements. One is the main part which sets out when the rent is to go up and how the increase is to be calculated with reference to the RPI; it should also provide for what happens if over the relevant period the RPI goes down. The other is...
            18-01-2019, 10:05 AM
          • Reply to Rent review issue
            flyingfreehold
            although one might think RPI linked leases give no room for maneouvre/negotiation; my experience is not so. Admittedly its rare but there was an occasion where RPI actually fell and this does result in possible differences in how the RPI linkage is calculated; which is why I would encourage making...
            18-01-2019, 05:13 AM
          • Reply to Rent review issue
            Lawcruncher
            A Calderbank offer is a special type of offer. It allows a party to make an offer which is without prejudice except as to costs. That is you can make the offer and then withdraw it. If you do withdraw it, it cannot be produced in court as evidence of your offer. However, if the other party held out...
            15-01-2019, 16:27 PM
          • Reply to Rent review issue
            rentreviewspecialist
            "I do know though that a Calderbank letter needs to comply with certain requirements and that one of them is that it contains a genuine compromise. Compromise is not applicable here…"

            A Calderbank is a without prejudice offer to compromise on the issue of costs. Compromise is...
            14-01-2019, 16:02 PM
          • Reply to Rent review issue
            Lawcruncher
            It does not though generally pay to give in to unreasonable requests. Give them an inch...

            By agreeing an increase lower than provided for you risk setting a precedent.

            Reasonableness does not really come into it. If you have a lease which provides for a rent of £10,000 p.a....
            14-01-2019, 08:54 AM
          • Reply to Rent review issue
            flyingfreehold
            This saga may end up in Court, with the tenant changing its mind and wanting to stay. Therefore I recommend you extract the office rpi figures and set out your calculations in the form of a letter, offering to settle at a few pounds less than your arithmetical calcs. Then if you do end up in Court the...
            14-01-2019, 05:28 AM
          • Reply to Rent review issue
            Lawcruncher
            If going for an RPI lease for your next tenant suggest to your solicitor he simplifies the RPI clauses. Starting from scratch with a precedent from a book would not be a bad idea.
            12-01-2019, 21:14 PM
          Working...
          X